Papenhuyzen stuns with four-try masterclass as Origin race heats up; Luai fails to fire
Melbourne Storm fullback Ryan Papenhuyzen left fans in awe with a sensational four-try performance that has dramatically boosted his chances of claiming the New South Wales No.1 jersey for the upcoming State of Origin series.
Papenhuyzen delivered one of the finest performances of his career in Storm’s record-breaking 64-0 thrashing of the Wests Tigers, overshadowing incumbent Blues fullback Dylan Edwards. The day after Edwards produced a lacklustre display in Penrith’s draw with the Cowboys, Papenhuyzen reignited the selection debate with an explosive showing.
By halftime, Papenhuyzen had already secured a hat-trick—his first try a dazzling solo effort that saw him regather his own kick twice before diving over. He ended the half with three tries, 99 running metres, and three tackle busts. “You never expect that in a game,” he told Fox Sports at the break, reflecting on the team’s strong performance and a productive week of training.
But he wasn’t done. Papenhuyzen added a fourth try and converted 10 goals, racking up 36 points—breaking the club record set by Mark Geyer in 1999. It marked the largest win in Melbourne Storm’s history and the third time in his career Papenhuyzen has scored four tries in a single match. He now tops the 2025 NRL try-scorer chart with 12.
With Origin selection looming, Papenhuyzen has thrown his name firmly into contention to replace Edwards, who despite running for 190 metres, was relatively quiet against the Cowboys. Some are even calling for a recall for veteran James Tedesco, who has been in excellent form for the Roosters, but coach Laurie Daley may opt for a fresher option like Papenhuyzen, who also offers value as a versatile bench utility.
Luai’s Origin hopes dim after Storm rout
Meanwhile, Jarome Luai’s hopes of holding onto his NSW No.6 jersey took a major hit as he struggled to make an impact during the Tigers’ heavy loss to the Storm. With Mitchell Moses putting in a subdued performance in Parramatta’s defeat to the Dolphins, the door was open for Luai to stake his claim—but he failed to seize the opportunity.
Despite some efforts to engage the defensive line, Luai couldn’t influence the game or inspire a Tigers comeback. It was a missed opportunity with only one more round left to impress before Daley names his squad for Game I at Suncorp Stadium.
While both Moses and Luai are currently playing halfback at club level, Luai has more experience in the five-eighth role. However, concerns have been raised—most notably by Phil Gould—about a possible Moses-Cleary halves pairing due to their preference for playing on the left side. Still, Eels coach Jason Ryles remains confident in Moses’ adaptability, stating that Moses would be willing to play anywhere for the Blues.
