Dylan Brown’s Shock Move to Newcastle Sparks Debate Over Timing and Impact
Parramatta Eels five-eighth Dylan Brown has sent shockwaves through the NRL by securing a record-breaking $13 million, 10-year deal with the Newcastle Knights.
NRL legends Mat Rogers and Scott Sattler have questioned the timing of Brown’s announcement, which came as Knights coach Jason Ryles faces mounting pressure. Reports surfaced on Monday afternoon that Brown had informed his Eels teammates of his decision to join Newcastle in 2026.
Shortly after, the 24-year-old seemingly confirmed the move on Instagram, while also reaffirming his commitment to giving his all for Parramatta in 2025. The deal is reportedly the richest in NRL history, with Brown set to pocket $13 million over a decade—a sum that would see him leave $6 million on the table if he had stayed with the Eels.
While opinions are divided on whether the Knights have landed a game-changing playmaker or taken a massive financial risk, the timing of the news has raised eyebrows. Reports suggest the Knights had no intention of pulling their offer following their weekend performance.
Eels Suffer Heavy Defeat as Brown’s Future is Revealed
Brown played a key role in Parramatta’s season opener against Melbourne Storm, wearing the No.6 jersey. However, the match turned into a disaster for the Eels, as Ryan Papenhuyzen and Cameron Munster orchestrated a 56-18 demolition at AAMI Park.
The loss reignited doubts over whether Brown is suited to the halfback role and if he is truly worth the massive contract the Knights have offered. Just a day later, Brown reportedly informed his teammates of his move to Newcastle, which sparked mixed reactions within the rugby league community.
Sattler and Rogers Question Brown’s Timing and Impact on Team Morale
NRL great Scott Sattler suggested that Brown’s signing could be a strategic move to persuade Kalyn Ponga to stay at Newcastle. With Ponga’s contract set to expire in 2027, there is speculation he could switch codes to rugby union or join the Roosters.
Comparisons were made to Justin Hodges’ controversial move in 2001, when he told Wayne Bennett he was leaving the Broncos for the Roosters—a decision that led to his immediate exclusion from the team.
Mat Rogers questioned whether the timing of Brown’s decision would further disrupt the Eels’ dressing room.
“One of your star players is telling his teammates he’s leaving? Would you want him there? Especially with a young coach trying to build something?”
Sattler expressed disbelief that Brown would reveal his move so close to the season opener, suggesting it could demoralize his teammates.
“Players understand, but it still stings. The message is clear—I don’t want to play with you guys long-term. That hurts,” Sattler said on SEN Radio.
Rogers also questioned whether Brown had truly proven himself in the halfback role to warrant such a long contract.
“How do you land a 10-year deal without proving you can steer a team? It screams desperation from Newcastle,” Rogers remarked.
Additionally, he warned that the pressure on Brown would only increase, particularly from Parramatta fans.
“If he has a bad game, Eels fans will come for him all year. The timing is just really poor for Jason Ryles,” he added.
Brown’s Departure Leaves Ryles With a Tough Rebuild at the Eels
With Brown set to depart, Ryles now faces the daunting task of reshaping an Eels side already tipped to struggle in 2025. Having already moved on captain Clint Gutherson and Reagan Campbell-Gillard, Ryles signaled his intention for a rebuild by introducing several young players in the season opener.
On the positive side, Brown’s exit frees up significant salary cap space for Parramatta, giving them a chance to recruit a marquee playmaker or fullback for 2026 and beyond. However, Sattler warned that money alone won’t be enough to attract big names.
“It puts them in a strong position for recruitment, but they have to win. Top players want to join clubs that are finals contenders. Based on week one, many stars may be hesitant,” Sattler said.
NRL Set for Major Transfer Domino Effect
Brown’s move could trigger a series of player transfers, reshaping the league landscape. The Eels have already been linked to Lachlan Galvin and Tyran Wishart as potential replacements.
Meanwhile, speculation continues to swirl around Kalyn Ponga’s future, with rumors suggesting the Roosters could make a play for the star fullback as Trent Robinson looks to reshape his squad after several high-profile departures in 2025.
